Emma Starletto and Harlow West have been friends for so long that their dads have also developed a friendship. They sometimes get together so the girls can hang out while the dads work out. Emma's dad, Charles Dera, and Harlow's dad, Dick Chibbles, are lifting weights as the girls quietly discuss how hot they find the workout session. Harlow claims she'd totally fuck Emma's dad, and Emma is on the same page about Harlow's dad.

The girls decide to at least tease each other's dads. They head to the bedroom to change into pajamas. While they're in there getting naked together, Harlow decides to take on another of her fantasies. She puts out there to Emma that she's feeling pretty horny, and doubles down on it by feeling up her boobs and hopping on the bed to slip her hands between her thighs. Emma has never done anything like this before, but watching Harlow diddle her own clit is so hot that Emma can't help but feel herself up, too. Fresh from their climaxes, the girls get dressed in their cute little PJs and return to the living room to see what mischief they can get into.

They find their dads sitting on the couch watching the game. Although Dick and Charles don't seem to much notice when the girls return, but the girls make themselves known by massaging their own dads. When they swap so that Emma is rubbing down Dick and Harlow is rubbing down Charles, the dads can't remain oblivious. Dick tries to disengage, but Charles is DTF. Eventually he convinces Dick to let Emma suck his cock while Harlow delivers the same treatment to Charles. Harlow hops onto Charles's fuck stick for a stiffie ride, and eventually Emma gets to do the same with Dick. The girls both take a doggy style pussy pounding from the other's dad. Then they go back to back as Dick bangs a climax out of Harlow and Charles does the same for Emma. The pussy pounding only ends when both dads have delivered a creampie, leaving Emma and Harlow smiling and sated.